Herbal cigarettes ignite criticism
01/17/00
YOU MIGHT NOT even notice Herbal
cigarettes with names like Herbal Gold or Ecstasy among other cigarettes, but sometimes they are prominently displayed. The packages boast that they are
tobacco free and nicotine free. Instead they may contain a variety of herbal ingredients, including ginseng, passionflower, wild lettuce and even catnip. According to the Centers for Disease Control, when they burn these products still produce tar and carbon monoxide and cancer-causing agents.
The New York City Department of Consumer Affairs reports that stores selling these
cigarettes to minors may not be violating the law.
Right now, it’s certainly unconscionable, but it certainly seems to evade the definition of
tobacco products under New York state law, said DEC Commissioner Jules Polenetsky.
In fact, Polenetsky said that the
cigarettes seem to be targeted to kids because of the bright colors, the names and the flavors. When Consumer Affairs asked teen-agers, they readily knew where to buy them and reported that they did purchase them.
They’re also dangerous because they make kids used to the idea of smoking something that smells like a cigarette, looks like a cigarette, even though they don’t have nicotine, Polenetsky said.
When NewsChannel4 spoke to the manufacturers of Ecstasy and Herbal Gold, they said that the critics have it all wrong.
Alternative Cigarettes, Inc. reports that they’re proud to offer herbal
cigarettes to
smokers as an alternative to
tobacco and nicotine. They pointed out their herbal packs warn that they are not intended for sale to minors along with various health warnings.
The Temple of Ecstasy Corp. insists that it takes thorough measures to make certain that kids don’t purchase their cigarettes. They said that each pack has the Surgeon General’s warning and, as of March, a clear note that indicates that sales to minors are prohibited.
Some high school students said that the products could encourage their classmates to smoke.
Later this week, the New York City Council is expected to raise fines and toughen penalties against stores selling
tobacco cigarettes to minors.
Polenetsky said that there could need to be further legislation to prohibit the sale of non-tobacco
cigarettes to minors.